Friday, August 13, 2010

Is Florida the next Arizona?


Florida Immigrant Crackdown Aims to Outdo Arizona Laws
State attorney general Bill McCollum promises harshest anti-illegal immigration legislation yet.

by Ed Pilkington

Florida's attorney general on Wednesday promised to introduce laws emulating - and exceeding - the draconian clampdown on undocumented immigrants recently attempted by Arizona.

'Arizona is going to want this law,' says Florida Attorney General and GOP gubernatorial candidate Bill McCollum. Architects of the plan boast they will be the harshest anti-illegal immigration laws yet, a claim that could have an incendiary effect in Florida given the state's high proportion of Latinos. (WILFREDO LEE / AP)
The proposed legislation would put the sunshine state at the forefront of the anti-immigrant moves rapidly sweeping across the US.

Architects of the plans boast they will be the harshest anti-illegal immigration laws yet, a claim that could have an incendiary effect in Florida given the state's high proportion of Latinos.

Bill McCollum, Florida's attorney general, is the main proponent of the clampdown. He said the legislation would "provide new enforcement tools for protecting our citizens and will help our state fight the on-going problems created by illegal immigration. Florida will not be a sanctuary state for illegal aliens."

Under the proposals, police would be required to investigate the immigration status of anyone they stopped whom they suspected of being illegally in the country. Any suspects lacking papers would be liable to up to 20 days in jail after which time they would be handed over to the immigration services for deportation.

In an innovation that goes beyond anything tried in Arizona, the Florida law would allow local courts to impose longer prison sentences and tougher bail conditions on anyone committing a crime in the state who is found to be undocumented.

Critics of the increasingly hostile mood of local politicians in states across America towards illegal immigrants accuse them of pandering to popular white prejudices towards Hispanics in order to garner electoral support.

In Florida's case, McCollum is currently embroiled in a close electoral fight to gain the Republican party's nomination for governor of the state ahead of elections in November.

His Republican rival for the candidacy, Rick Scott, accused McCollum of devising policy specifically for electoral gain. His spokesman told the Miami Herald: "It's clear the only way to get McCollum to take any action on anything is when he's down in the polls."

McCollum and his supporters in Florida are highly mindful of the fact that Arizona's attempt to force the police to check on the immigration status of suspected undocumented workers has been blocked by the federal government in a legal dispute that is likely to go all the way to the supreme court.

McCollum claims to have avoided a similar challenge from the Obama administration by being more specific about the circumstances under which officers are obliged to check immigration papers.

In particular, McCollum said the proposed new rules would avoid any whiff of racial profiling against Hispanics - an accusation widely levelled at Arizona where the vast majority of undocumented residents are Mexican.

Under the planned law, police would need to have a concrete reason for suspicion such as an altered driving licence or an admission from the suspect that they were in the country without permission.

"It's not how you look, it's not what you say," McCollum said.

Despite his insistence that his proposals would be less likely to provoke federal intervention, they are likely to face a challenge. The Obama administration is alarmed that immigration policy is spinning out of its control as individual states seek to make their own rules.

1 comment:

  1. Americans are required to have a social security number and a license if they are operating a vehicle in the United States. Americans are stopped and checked to ensure no violations of the law are taking place. This should be the case for everyone within the boundaries of the United States of America. However, it should not lead to profiling of any kind because humans deserve to be treated with dignity and respect. As a result, McCollum's proposal may need to be more narrow to ensure that profiling and discrimination does not take place.

    It is understandable that people from other countries want to live in America due to possible better opportunities and/or a better life for their family. However, countries have rules in place that their citizens and non-citizens within their boundaries have to follow. Furthermore, when visiting and/or relocating it is important to respect the country and its citizens. I have friends who immigrated to Florida legally from places like Cuba, Puerto Rico, Mexico, etc. and they are disappointed that many people who immigrate to Florida illegally disrespect the United States by refusing to learn English and discriminating against citizens of the United States.

    I believe that people should be able to immigrate to the United States legally and should be aided in doing so. Those who are in the United States illegally should be given a chance to gain legal status. Also, those who immigrate should follow the same laws that citizens of the United States follow and should respect the citizens and culture of the United States.


Nuestras Voces welcomes passionate and respectful commentary. The administrator will delete comments that insult or threaten other blog participants or that fall outside of the bounds of respectful discourse. Trolling, spamming and other annoying behaviors are strictly prohibited. In the rare event that your post has been deleted, do not post comments regarding that fact. Peace!